BEING HEUMANN Review

Most biopics are cradle-to-grave homework. You sit down, they hand you a syllabus, and by the ninety-minute mark you have learned a great deal and enjoyed approximately none of it. Being Heumann looks at that format, flips it the finger, and then does something I did not expect from a film about federal legislation: it throws a party.
Ruth Madeley plays Judy Heumann, and the film introduces her zipping down a New York street in 1972, a wheelchair user in a city with no curb cuts, getting stared at and yelled at and responding with a raised middle finger. That is the whole character in thirty seconds. Madeley is funny and flinty and spiky and smarter than everyone in the room. She plays Judy as a leader who is also, let’s be honest, quite pushy, which is exactly what the job required. It is a true star turn and I would like her to be handed everything immediately.
Siân Heder, following up CODA, makes the smartest decision available to her and zeroes in on one stretch of Judy’s life. Section 504 has been signed into law but never implemented, because it needs one signature from a nervous Secretary Califano (Mark Ruffalo), who is terrified of the budget and keen to remind everyone he once supported Selma. He will not sign. So Judy and her people take over a federal building in San Francisco, and the film turns into something frisky. There is in-fighting, government pressure, real stakes, some joy, and also, yes, sex tents. I did not know I needed a historical drama with sex tents. I do now.

The casting is what makes this sing. Heder fills the screen with disabled performers, including Madeline Delp, Daniel Durant, and the instantly memorable Charlie Rush Reese, and the result feels real rather than like a very nice tribute written by outsiders. The one flaw is that there are so many colorful characters, each deserving of their own movie, that unfortunately a few threads get dropped along the way. That is a good problem to have, but it is still a problem.
Being Heumann is going to be called rousing. Fine. It is. But it is also a film that refuses to treat activism as a vegetable you must finish before dessert, and I have rarely seen history this alive.
Be more like Judy. Be tough, and never be afraid of joy.
🍿 SCORE = 82 / 100




Comments