top of page
  • YouTube
  • Twitter/X
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

I PLAY ROCKY Review

15 hours ago
4 min read
Promotional poster for I Play Rocky

"Just do the best acting of your life and everything will be fine."


Since the dawn of cinema, we've had a constant bombardment of biopics on famous people shoved in our faces. Unless they're doing something along the lines of Malcolm X or The Social Network, where they're doing a character study exploring the person who made an impact on society in a compelling way, most of them tend to take a surface-level approach to the story. So, when it was announced that the Academy Award-winning director of Green Book, Peter Farrelly, would tackle I Play Rocky, I immediately checked out.


But after it took the runner-up spot at TIFF for the People's Choice Award and won a few audience prizes at other festivals, I became mildly curious about seeing the film. So, I grabbed a ticket to see what the fuss was all about. And unfortunately, I wasn't moved by the film at all and was perplexed by what they wanted to accomplish in telling this behind-the-scenes story of making the Best Picture winner that others have already told.


I Play Rocky revolves around Sylvester Gardenzio Stallone (Anthony Ippolito) and his struggles in getting an acting gig in New York City. To keep up with rent after the failed auditions, he decides to become an usher at a local movie theater, where he meets his eventual wife, Sasha Czack (AnnaSophia Robb), and gets inspired to write screenplays. Eventually, Sylvester delivers a first draft of Rocky to film producers Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell). Despite attempting to buy the script off of Sly without him in it, the producers persuade United Artists to make the film with the struggling actor on a reduced budget. With the odds stacked against them, they'll have to make the film under budget and on time or else the entire shoot is scrapped.


Peter Farrelly has pivoted in his career from doing gross-out comedies like Dumb and Dumber and There's Something About Mary to directing biographical films like The Greatest Beer Run Ever and Green Book; the latter of which controversially won Best Picture at the Academy Awards. And while he's able to get decent performances from most of his actors, there isn't a unique voice or point-of-view in telling this story. Even the filmmaking seems standard and comes off like a television film.


Still from I Play Rocky: two boxers sit on a locker room bench, one with taped hands and a towel over his shoulder, the other in headgear and a single glove.

Even if I were to put my problems with the director off to the side for a moment, I kept asking myself, "What was the point of making a behind-the-scenes look at this in movie form?" In something like Ed Wood, we saw the friendship being formed between the titular character himself and Bela Lugosi over the course of making movies together. Even The Disaster Artist provided an interesting angle on the making of The Room, while having James Franco and Dave Franco play the real-life best friends Tommy Wiseau and Greg Sestero going through their ups and downs. Both provided entertaining stories while celebrating the films that made their real-life counterparts so famous.


With I Play Rocky, it didn't seem like there was much of a point, outside of recreating the iconic, classic moments from the original film. Was it the fact that they wanted to turn what could be an interesting story into another paint-by-numbers biopic without diving deep into Sly himself? Or was it to be an inspirational film for those who believe they can "go the distance"? Either way, it doesn't provide an intriguing angle on the story.


If there were any positives I could bring up, I do think the cast did fine for the most part. Anthony Ippolito definitely captures the mannerisms of Sly but doesn't embody a character who feels believable; if nothing else, he has more range than Jaafar Jackson did in Michael. AnnaSophia Robb actually impressed me even though she wasn't given a terrific role. I could tell she was trying to create a character despite the part being the typical "supportive wife" archetype. I did like the film crew they cast, particularly Toby Kebbell and P.J. Byrne, as they elicited some legit chuckles from me.


Still from I Play Rocky: a dark-haired man in a denim shirt holds a thick script in a 1970s office with a patterned couch and a desk.

The rest of the film is told in a surface-level, generic approach. There's not much in here that's interesting or fascinating that you haven't already found while researching the making of the Oscar-winning film. Not that I expect it to tell me new information, but there are biopics that try to get out of that formulaic sandbox by either attempting to do something different or to add a unique voice. If anything, it just reminded me that we're likely getting more of these types of biopics, where we don't see an intriguing way of exploring the character. Rather, we'll be getting more of these safe, pedestrianly told films, focusing on how an iconic moment of said person's life happened without diving deep into their reasoning behind creating it.


It also made me appreciate what the original film was doing in that it did have this passion and creativity within its own storytelling. Obviously, this isn't trying to remake the whole story, but there was something to it that struck a chord with audiences over 50 years ago. So, a giant studio like Amazon trying to capture lightning in a bottle again is impossible. And if you are going to do it, provide an interesting angle.


If you want my advice, watch the original Rocky. If you want to know more about the making of the film itself, there are probably tons of books and documentaries out there that'll provide an interesting look at how it was made.


As for I Play Rocky... your best bet is to vote with your wallet by seeing another film.


🍿 SCORE = 45/100

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

LEAVE A MESSAGE AFTER THE BEEP

Please take a moment to fill out the form.

Thanks for submitting!

©️ The Awards Garage 2026-2035

bottom of page